After writing about the government’s five-a-day guidelines for how to be a good parent a few weeks ago, I was surprised to see that “five things to be a good parent” is one of the top searches bringing people to the Bump blog. I guess a lot of that traffic is driven by people looking to find out more about the coalition government’s proposed campaign, but I also read this article about so-called parenting experts, and it got me thinking about why we feel we need so much advice these days¹…and how reliable all this advice we get actually is.
Back when I was pregnant – in those heady, care-free days before I understood the true meaning of the words “not enough hours in the day” – I bought every parenting book on the market. My appetite for information was voracious. I believed that in parenting, like in every other area of life, if you fail to prepare, you prepare to fail.
I think I realised I’d been labouring (no pun intended) under a misapprehension when I handed the Birth Plan to my midwife. She gave me a wry sort of smile and said, “Ah, a first timer…” and that was the last I saw of that.
Nearly eleven months later and 99% of the books I bought either lie unread (and now under a thick layer of grime slightly dusty) on the shelf in the nursery, or are missing, presumed borrowed/puked on/eaten. I’ve been so busy learning to be a parent that I’ve had no time to learn to parent. While I remain steadfastly jealous of anyone who has managed to follow The Plan and eke out a little oasis of calm in the howling, shrieking, oh-god-oh-god-oh-god confusion of early parenthood, it just wasn’t for us. Partly because I never seem to have the time to read any parenting books, but mostly because I’m a lazy arse by nature, who is more likely to spend my meagre free time lolling in front of Stargate SG1 than swotting up.
Despite my lack of studying, however, it’s fair to say that some truly great advice has poured in from all quarters. Some of it has really saved my bacon at times, so I thank everyone who has been forthcoming (you know who you are). But good advice is boring boring boring, right? So instead, here are my top five pieces of advice about pregnancy and parenting that have turned out to be Absolute Horse Shit.
1. “Just relax! Stressing out about getting pregnant will only make it harder!”
Okay, first off, I’m not stressed, I’m excited. If I was stressed, I’d be drinking gin in the pub like any normal human being, not weeing on a stick every forty-five minutes. Secondly, the effect of stress on the luteinizing hormone required for ovulation is questionable, at best, and even then you’re talking about death-divorce-moving-home stress, not just getting a bit enthusiatic about having a baby. Some people take it as it comes; some people chart and temp and POAS. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: judge not, lest ye be judged.
2. “Your vegetarian baby is probably lacking in iron/protein/vitamins/meaty goodness [delete as applicable].”
Not one single health professional that I have spoken to about bringing up a vegetarian baby has ever had anything bad to say about it. In fact, quite the opposite. According to one, most babies have too much protein in their diet anyway. Another told me that vegetarian babies have a lower instance of illness. Yet another had three vegetarian-from-birth children of her own. So no. I’m not going to “try them on a little bit of chicken (’cause some vegetarians eat chicken, you know).”²
3. “Make bath time part of your baby’s bedtime routine to relax her before she goes to sleep.”
Does this baby look relaxed to you?
Yeah, we have baths in the morning now.
4. “For a more natural breastfeeding experience, lay baby on your chest while you lie down and let them find the nipple themselves.”
Wait, what? You want me to take one of the most agonising, infuriating, technically complicated things I’ve ever done in my life and try to do it UPSIDE DOWN? Find it themselves? Honey, I love my baby, but at six weeks old, I honestly think my cat knows more about life, the universe and nipples. (Not that I breastfed my cat. I went a bit fucking loopy for a few months there³, but not That Loopy.)
5. “Give your baby some Nappy Off Time to help clear up her nappy rash.”
This is actually brilliant advice. But it should always, always, ALWAYS have the caveat, “…but on your own head – or, as the case may be, favourite rug – be it.”
God, now I’ve started, I can think of hundreds more. There was the woman who told me off in BHS for eating a cheddar cheese sandwich while pregnant(!); the advice I found online that told me my baby would surely suffocate if she shared a cot with her beloved Roo, but that propping her bottle while I did the housework was fine; the NHS video of a water birth where the mother smiles serenely the whole way through (yep, even the Ring of Fire bit). Being a parent is a manure-strewn minefield.
So come on: share your stories of hilariously bad parenting and pregnancy advice. Perhaps I’ll even turn it into a regular feature on the blog. Those are the kind of parenting tips worth searching Google for…
¹ If you’re interested, I have this comment on BabyCalm that sums up some of my views on parenting advice.
² No they don’t. They really, really don’t.
³ I will get around to writing about my PND. I will.